The Epic Struggle of Picky Eaters

Friendly FYI: this site uses affiliate links. If you buy something, we might earn a small commission. Without your support, this site wouldn't be possible. Thank you! For more information, visit our Disclaimer Page.

As a parent, you’ve likely faced the dramatic challenge of mealtimes with your picky eater. It’s like trying to reason with a screaming toddler version of Scar from The Lion King! No matter how creatively you whip up balanced meals with stealthy hidden veggies, your little one pushes away the plate with a chorus of “yucks” and “gross” (if you’re lucky).

It leaves you feeling more perplexed than Alice in Wonderland trying to make sense of the Mad Hatter’s tea party. You’re left wondering:

  • Is my child getting adequate nutrition on chicken nuggets and macaroni alone?
  • Are family dinners always going to resemble a battle scene from Mulan?
  • Why is my once adventurous eater now so averse to trying new foods?

Take heart, fellow parents. You aren’t alone on this quest to expand your picky eater’s limited food horizons. With patience, creativity, and a splash of Disney magic, you can gently encourage less selective eating habits over time. Let’s explore some common causes and strategies to try.

Why Do Little Ones Become Picky Eaters?

Picky eating often stems from basic human survival instincts. We’re evolutionarily wired to avoid foods that seem poisonous or toxic. It’s like your child has their own “Poison Apple Detector” from Snow White! Of course you know the applesauce you’re serving is perfectly safe, but their primal senses don’t trust it.

Additional factors that shape picky eating include:

  • Flavor preferences starting in the womb based on mom’s pregnancy diet. It’s like your baby developed their “taste bud palate” from the amniotic fluid!
  • Breastfed babies growing accustomed to flavors passed through breastmilk, then rejecting the taste of formula or solid foods.
  • Toddlers exerting independence and control through refusal of food, like a pint-sized princess declaring “I shan’t eat my vegetables! Off with their heads!”
  • Sensory issues with food temperatures, textures, or mixing flavors. The cold crunch of a carrot may be uncomfortably jarring.
  • Anxious eaters fixating on “safe foods” and fearing anything new.

The good news? Research shows that with consistent exposure to new foods, kids typically grow out of picky eating by elementary school. Phew! Your hard work now pays off.

Enchanting Strategies to Open Up Picky Palates

Picky eater girl

With fairy godmother levels of patience and creativity, you can gently expand your picky eater’s limited repertoire:

  • Involve them in preparing meals – children get excited tasting foods they helped cook, just like Remy the rat in Ratatouille!
  • Relate new foods to favorite storybooks or TV characters. “Big Bird loves broccoli trees! Want to try some trees?”
  • Offer new foods alongside familiar ones at first. New seems less scary with trusty mac ‘n cheese nearby.
  • Make tasting new foods fun with cookie cutters, plates with divided sections, or cutting into shapes.
  • Model enjoying fruits, veggies, and variety yourself. Monkey see, monkey do!
  • Stick with consistently offering new foods. It can take 10-15 exposures before a child accepts something new.
  • Go for tiny tastes at first – just a lick of hummus or spoonful of beets. Small steps!
  • Involve kids in meal planning and grocery shopping so they feel ownership.
  • Focus on descriptions that pique interest – “sweet corn” “crunchy apple” “juicy pineapple”.
  • Offer rewards for bravery in trying, but don’t force it if they refuse after a taste. You catch more flies with honey than vinegar!

Fun Books and Products for Picky Eaters

In addition to tips and strategies, there are some great books and products out there designed just for picky eaters! Here are a few you can try:

“Green Eggs and Ham” by Dr. Seuss – This classic story shows the silliness of refusing to try something new in a fun, rhyming way.

Green Eggs and Ham

“I Will Never Not Ever Eat a Tomato” by Lauren Child – Follow a picky eater’s creative ways to avoid eating fruits and veggies.

I Will Never Not Ever Eat a Tomato (Charlie and Lola)

Plates for Picky Eaters – Plates featuring their favorite TV or book characters can make mealtime more engaging.

Enchanted Forest Kid's Dinner Tray - Award Winning - Picky Eater Solutions for Kids and Toddlers - Fun Mealtime - Divided Sections - Interactive Design - Dishwasher Safe

Food Dehydrator – Make homemade fruit leathers or veggie chips to make produce more appealing.

Magic Mill Food Dehydrator Machine

Calling In the Cooking Cavalry

See a pediatrician, occupational therapist, or feeding therapist when:

  • Nutritional deficiencies arise because diet lacks variety. Can’t live on PB&Js alone!
  • Mealtimes routinely become battlegrounds with tears, tantrums or power struggles. No one should dread dinner time.
  • Picky eating interferes with social events like birthday parties or camp lunch. Don’t let finicky eating isolate kids.
  • Food repertoire doesn’t progress with time. If 2-3 safe foods remain the only options after a few years, seek help getting unstuck.

Patience & Persistence Conquer Picky Eating

Expanding your picky eater’s limited food comfort zones requires oodles of gentle patience and persistent creativity from parents, plus modeling enjoyment of variety ourselves.

With time and continuous exposure to flavors through sensory play, stories, rewards and no-pressure tastings, picky eating usually improves. Mealtimes become relaxing teamwork rather than daily battles.

Take heart and keep offering new foods with love. Like Rafiki said, “It takes patience to make a man.” Ok, he didn’t actually say that, but it’s still true! With openness, imagination and relaxed persistence, your child’s tastes will gradually blossom from chicken nuggets and buttered noodles into a world of flavorful foods. Before you know it, your formerly finicky eater will wolf down spinach-artichoke dip like Kronk devouring Marge’s spinach puffs!

For even more tips on dealing with picky eaters, check out helpful resources like the “10 Tips for Picky Eaters” article from and the strategies in “The Terrible Twos: Toddler Tantrum Triggers” for handling mealtime meltdowns gracefully. With the right mix of patience, creativity and support, you can guide your picky eater to a world of food enjoyment!

Hey there! I'm Allen, but you can call me "The Corny Dad" from Canada. I have a wife and four kiddos. Yep, one's full grown, but they'll always be my babies. When I'm not doing something with my family or playing video games, I'm here, jotting down my bits of wisdom on this blog. From the fun stuff to the parenting chaos, I cover it all. Believe me, with the right attitude, parenting's a smoother ride and I'm here to help.

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles